SalesGenius: I just had to try it


Today, SalesGenius was launched, and when I understood that it it ultimately a form of phishing, I just had to try it out. (Like Mimi says in Rent, “I was born to be bad.”)

Here’s how it works: the salesperson, presumably, sends email to her prospective customer using the SalesGenius website (the Outlook plug-in is still in beta.) As part of the email, the sales rep includes a link to her own company’s website. And here’s where the phishing (and the intended value) come in. The link automatically redirects through the SalesGenius server, rsvp1, so the url comes up looking like this: However, the unsuspecting potential customer doesn’t realize that he was redirected unless he happens to look at the address bar, because the page is the same as the one he is expecting to see. The salesperson can now get on her account at SalesGenius and see which recipient of her email clicked to the site, which pages the potential customer looked at, in what order he looked at them, and how long he stayed on each page.

To test it out, I created a free 30-day account. Then I sent email from my new SalesGenius account to three web analytic/conversion rate bloggers – I just told them that I was testing invasive software and asked them to click around my site, on more than one page. When I created the email, I was going to create a naked link,, but the SalesGenius software encouraged me to bury my site link in a phrase, like this.

Here you can see the first screen shot, where Pat McCarthy from Conversion Rater was on the site while I was looking, Clint Ivy from Instant Cognition had opened the email but not visited the site, and Eric Butler from Inside Analytics has already been to my site.

Next, I could select any of the people who had clicked through to the site and see what pages they had visited and for how long:
Finally, I was able to “replay” their visit:

This last step seemed a little redundant, I had already seen it (albeit by page name) in the step before, but if the URL names are not very descriptive, or the clickstream was a long one (or the salesperson doesn’t know the website well) it might be helpful.

You can imagine how much I disliked the deception here. Here is an excellent review on CNET, The Case of the Spying Salesman. It’s also worth looking at the very interesting comments on the TechCrunch review earlier today.

Many thanks to Eric, Pat and Clint for their help.

Robbin Steif

Our owner and CEO, Robbin Steif, started LunaMetrics twelve years ago. She is a graduate of Harvard College and the Harvard Business School, and has served on the Board of Directors for the Digital Analytics Association. Robbin is a winner of a BusinessWomen First award, as well as a recent Diamond Award for business leadership. You should read her letter before you decide to work with us.

  • Clint

    You Sneaky Sneaky Snake! I first just went to and didn’t see anything obvious so I thought maybe you were split testing or test serving so I used the link in the e-mail (after reviewing it in the status bar) and I knew I was going to different server but figured it was a-purpose.

    Can’t imagine my chagrin and feeling of violation when I saw this post and my name front and center.

    I’d be careful how you test though 😉 could be seen as a violation of the WAA Statement of principles.

    J/K – Thanks for raising this kind of less-than-ethical tactic with the appropriate light.

Contact Us.


24 S. 18th Street, Suite 100,
Pittsburgh, PA 15203

Follow Us



We'll get back to you
in ONE business day.